No.40 originally No.4 and No.42 was No.6.
1881. MCC BR: James Garton to build for self two 2-storey houses. Mr. Gall of Collins Street - architect. Brick, 10 rooms.
1881. Name mentioned: Jas. Garton J.P.
1885. James Garton - owner of both houses. Occupiers: James Garton, for the other J. Inglis.
James Garton of Garton's Horse Bazaar, 227 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.